News

Appeal lost: Dealer fined 200,000, ordered to refund R276,000 after car engine failed two days into ownership

todayNovember 16, 2026 3

Background
share close

The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has dismissed a motor dealer’s appeal against an order compelling it to refund a consumer R276,607 (https://iol.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-04-10-dealership-fined-r200000-and-ordered-to-refund-cape-town-man-over-r270000-after-car-broke-down-two-days-into-ownership/) for a used Ford Ranger whose engine failed two days after purchase.

The court also upheld a R200,000 administrative fine imposed on WP Motors Sales, trading as WP Motors, after finding that it had failed to honour the consumer’s election to cancel the transaction.

Judge Mj Teffo, with Acting Judge N Kekana concurring, found that the dealer had contravened the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) by refusing to refund the purchase price despite the consumer’s decision to return the vehicle.

The dispute arose after Franklin Pretorius purchased a used 2015 Ford Ranger from WP Motors on January 17, 2020, at a financed price of R276,607.49.

The car, with a recorded mileage of 115,567 kilometres, suffered a devastating engine failure (https://www.iol.co.za/news/south-africa/kwazulu-natal/pics-kzn-man-left-in-distress-after-paying-over-r15-000-to-service-his-polo-which-was-later-stripped-at-a-dealership-f322d5a3-fa2b-4912-8f98-e483ea7d7435) on January 19, 2020, during a drive by Pretorius’s father from Cape Town to Heidelberg, Gauteng.

Pretorius immediately informed the dealer in writing that he was returning the vehicle and subsequently demanded cancellation of the sale.

However, WP Motors refused to cancel the transaction and instead arranged for the engine to be rebuilt, attributing the failure to alleged driver negligence.

The dealer maintained that Pretorius was not entitled to a refund.

The court noted that Pretorius had been without the vehicle and his money for more than six years while continuing to pay instalments to MFC, a division of Nedbank, which financed the purchase.

The National Consumer Commission investigated the complaint before referring the matter to the National Consumer Tribunal.

In February 2025, the tribunal found that WP Motors had contravened sections 55(2)(b), 55(2)(c) and 56(2)(b) of the CPA.

It declared the dealer’s conduct prohibited, ordered it to refund the purchase price and imposed a R200,000 administrative fine.

WP Motors subsequently appealed against the entire ruling.

In dismissing the appeal, the High Court found that a vehicle whose engine fails during its first long-distance journey, two days after being sold as roadworthy, cannot reasonably be regarded as being of good quality, in good working order or durable for a reasonable period.

The court rejected the dealer’s reliance on reports blaming the driver for the engine failure.

It found that the reports from the repairer and another vehicle centre were unsupported by proper expert evidence, with neither author testifying or explaining the diagnostic procedures used.

The court said the dealer had elected not to call any witnesses, despite the consumer testifying and being cross-examined.

It also rejected WP Motors’ argument that Pretorius had abandoned his cancellation demand by taking delivery of the vehicle in June 2020 and allegedly driving it for more than 10,000km.

The court found that the alleged mileage was not proved and that the consumer’s explanation for temporarily taking the vehicle back was credible.

Pretorius had testified that he accepted delivery after being threatened with storage charges and because he feared the vehicle was being used while in the dealer’s custody.

He also wanted to safeguard the vehicle while pursuing his complaint through the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa.

The court found that his temporary possession of the vehicle did not amount to abandoning his election to cancel the transaction.

It further rejected the dealer’s argument that the complaint was time-barred, finding that the Commission’s referral to the tribunal was within the three-year period prescribed by the CPA.

The court also refused to deduct an amount for the consumer’s alleged use of the vehicle, finding that the claimed mileage had not been established.

The National Consumer Commission had separately sought to increase the R200,000 fine to 10% of WP Motors’ annual turnover or R1 million.

However, its cross-appeal was filed late, prompting an application for condonation.

The court refused the application, finding that the Commission had failed to adequately explain its delay and that its prospects of success were poor.

It said the tribunal’s fine was not shown to be disproportionate and that there was no evidence of the dealer’s annual turnover before the tribunal.

The Commission was ordered to pay WP Motors’ costs of the condonation application and cross-appeal.

The High Court dismissed WP Motors’ appeal and ordered it to pay the Commission’s legal costs.

sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za

IOL News

Get your news on the go. Download the latest IOL App for Android (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.iol.news.prod&hl=en_ZA&pli=1) and IOS (https://apps.apple.com/za/app/iol-news/id479535200) now.

Written by: IOL News

Rate it

Previous post

Sports

McCarthy outlines plans to dismantle Bafana in harsh Kenya conditions

Kenya head coach Benni McCarthy (https://iol.co.za/sport/soccer/bafana/2026-11-14-homecoming-sting-benni-mccarthy-praises-kenyas-character-after-bafana-bafana-draw/) is confident his side can pose a greater threat to Bafana Bafana when the two nations meet in Tuesday’s return AFCON qualifier at Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi. The Harambee Stars will take confidence from Friday’s 2-2 draw at Orlando Amstel Arena (https://iol.co.za/sport/soccer/2026-11-13-bafana-bafana-suffer-stoppage-time-heartbreak-as-kenya-snatch-draw-after-defensive-lapse/), where they twice came from behind to deny Pitso Mosimane’s (https://iol.co.za/sport/soccer/bafana/2026-11-12-mosimane-insists-club-workload-wont-stop-him-from-selecting-appollis-for-bafana/) men victory on home soil. Having seen his players compete […]

todayNovember 16, 2026


Magic 828

Magic 828 AM is a South African commercial radio station playing the best of hits from the 80s, 90s and 2000’s

Download Our App

Don’t miss a track or memorable tune. Download the Magic828 App now on your mobile phone by clicking here!

0%