Rassie Erasmus (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-16-springboks-determined-to-restore-standards-against-ireland-after-paris-disappointment/) has questioned whether match officials who knowingly ignore foul play (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-17-hell-play-on-saturday-rassie-blasts-terrible-sam-prendergast-hip-drop-tackle/) could be accused of influencing a Test match’s outcome.
The fuming Springbok coach also launched a stinging attack on what he sees as inconsistencies in rugby’s disciplinary process.
Speaking ahead of Saturday’s Nations Championship showdown against Ireland in Dublin, (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-16-rassie-reshuffles-springboks-pack-as-eben-etzebeth-returns-for-ireland-showdown/) Erasmus revisited the Boks’ 21-19 defeat to France in Paris, claiming Les Bleus escaped punishment for a series of dangerous knee-drop tackles.
He also questioned how an incident involving Ireland flyhalf Sam Prendergast was handled, after the player was cited on Monday for a hip-drop tackle that injured Fiji captain Peceli Yato during their 43-15 victory over former Springbok coach Jake White’s team.
Erasmus suggested the 23-year-old would nevertheless escape suspension and be available to face the Boks, drawing on what he believes has been an uneven experience with disciplinary decisions in the northern hemisphere.
“We are in the northern hemisphere. I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play,” Erasmus said.
He pointed to the cases of Springboks Lood de Jager, Jan-Hendrik Wessels and Franco Mostert, as well as the contrasting punishments handed to Wessels and Ireland prop Tadhg Furlong for similar groin-grabbing incidents.
Wessels received a nine-week ban, while Furlong received no punishment. (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/urc/2026-10-30-tadhg-furlong-free-to-play-for-ireland-after-urc-citing-complaint-dismissed/)
“From a South African point of view, that hurt, because we felt it was more or less the same situation,” Erasmus said.
“I’m not saying anybody is doing anything wrong. I’m just not expecting him to get cited and then play on Saturday.”
However, his biggest frustration is the apparent disconnect between the laws and interpretations discussed at World Rugby meetings and what subsequently happens on the field.
Erasmus said coaches had spent three hours at a recent World Summit discussing hip-drop tackles, with repeated video examples showing exactly what constituted the dangerous technique.
He felt Prendergast’s challenge on Yato was a clear example and should have resulted in a red card.
“We all had input. So when you see that and decide there’s nothing wrong with it, what do the other coaches or other people feel?” he asked.
“What did Jake feel when one of his players got injured and was carried off? We all thought it was an immediate red card. Everybody watched the game live because that’s exactly what they said a hip-drop tackle is.”
Erasmus then returned to the France Test, claiming the hosts made17 knee-drop tackles that went unpunished.
Of those, he believed 11 warranted at least a penalty and three should have resulted in yellow cards. There was no subsequent citing.
The coach was careful not to accuse the match officials of deliberately favouring France, but questioned the consequences if dangerous play was spotted and consciously ignored.
“If he didn’t see it, that’s a different thing. But if he saw it and decided to ignore it, what is that?” Erasmus asked.
“Is that not interfering with the outcome of a game? Is that not manipulation of the game or the result, or players getting injured?”
The Bok coach argued that calls for TMOs to stay out of matches could undermine two fundamental priorities: player safety and ensuring the correct team wins.
“If you want a TMO to stay out, two things happen. Firstly, player welfare is being promoted in the game and is a priority. Secondly, the right team must win.
“So if you see something that should be penalised or yellow-carded and you ignore it, the conclusion must be that you’re influencing the result of the game, or you’re letting somebody get hurt.”
Erasmus insisted he was not accusing anyone, nor suggesting the Springboks were being deliberately targeted.
He said he wanted to highlight the uncertainty that can arise when teams from different rugby cultures encounter disciplinary systems and interpretations they do not always understand.
“I’m not moaning. I’m just trying to give you a perspective of somebody who comes and plays against, for example, France or Ireland,” he said.
For Erasmus, the issue is bigger than whether Prendergast makes it onto the field on Saturday. It is about consistency between what rugby’s lawmakers tell coaches, what match officials enforce, and what disciplinary panels ultimately decide.