COMMENT
There was something rather ironic about Hugo Broos (https://iol.co.za/capetimes/sport/2026-08-25-gayton-mckenzie-reveals-hugo-broos-r14-million-salary-amid-safa-battle/) and his former assistant Helman Mkhalele being in the stands at Orlando Amstel Arena on Friday night, watching Bafana Bafana under Pitso Mosimane. (https://iol.co.za/sport/soccer/2026-11-13-bafana-bafana-suffer-stoppage-time-heartbreak-as-kenya-snatch-draw-after-defensive-lapse/)
The former technical team were there as spectators this time, but they could hardly have missed the familiar noise surrounding the national team’s selection decisions.
Mosimane (https://iol.co.za/sport/soccer/bafana/2026-11-14-bafana-too-good-too-pretty–but-no-finishing-touch-pitso-mosimane-frustrated-by-kenya-draw/) is beginning to experience the kind of scrutiny that followed Broos during his tenure, with supporters questioning omissions, debating the coach’s choices and demanding opportunities for players they believe deserve to wear the national team jersey.
Broos knew all about that pressure.
During his time in charge, the Belgian found himself defending decisions to leave out players such as Thembinkosi Lorch and Gift Links, despite their impressive club form. Supporters also questioned other selection calls, but Broos was rarely willing to bend to public opinion.
He made it clear that social media pressure would not dictate his selections.
Now Mosimane is facing a similar conversation.
His decision to leave out in-form defender Aden McCarthy, while recalling Mbekezeli Mbokazi, attracted attention ahead of the Kenya double-header.
The debate intensified when Mbokazi was left on the bench for Friday’s 2-2 draw, with supporters questioning whether the Chicago Fire defender should have started.
The omission of veteran midfielder Themba Zwane also generated discussion, particularly after Mosimane revealed how difficult the decision had been and that he had personally contacted the player to explain it.
There are clear similarities between the two coaches. Both have strong convictions about the players they want, both have had to justify unpopular decisions and both have faced questions about whether current club form should carry greater weight in national-team selection.
But there is a distinction worth making.
Broos established a clear selection philosophy built around technical ability, mentality and a player’s contribution to the team environment. He was prepared to make unpopular calls and, eventually, his results gave him the authority to stand by them.
His Bafana side reached the semi-finals of the 2023 Africa Cup of Nations and qualified for the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Mosimane is still at the beginning of his latest Bafana journey. His opening victories offered encouragement, but Friday’s draw against Kenya showed that performances and selection decisions will be judged together.
The presence of Broos and Mkhalele in the stands added an amusing subplot. One could almost imagine the former coaching duo watching the unfolding debate and recognising a few familiar headaches.
At least this time, they did not have to answer questions about the starting XI at the post-match press conference.
Ultimately, Mosimane should not select players simply to satisfy supporters. That is not how international football works.
However, he must understand that every omission creates a conversation, particularly when the player being left out is performing well.
Broos eventually earned the benefit of the doubt through results and consistency. Mosimane will need to do the same.
The question is not whether he can avoid criticism. No Bafana coach can. It is whether he can build a team good enough to make those arguments less important.