There is a compelling argument that Malcolm Marx is currently one of the most valuable players, if not the most, in the Springboks (https://iol.co.za/tags/springboks/) pack, and that they can ill afford to play the World Rugby Player of the Year off the bench when they take on the likes of New Zealand, France, England and Ireland.
As long as there is no other Bok hooker who can come close to matching what Marx brings (https://iol.co.za/sport/opinion/2026-11-15-springboks-needed-a-bloody-nose-to-sharpen-their-2026-rugby-world-cup-ambitions/) to the team, South Africa simply cannot leave him out of the starting XV for the biggest Tests.
The gulf between Marx and the other hookers in the queue was on display again on Friday against France in Paris in the 21-19 Nations Championship loss (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-15-springboks-lock-ruan-nortj-admits-france-defeat-is-a-tough-one-to-swallow/). While hooker Jan-Hendrik Wessels, who was called into the starting line-up at the eleventh hour, did not put a foot wrong and scored a good try from a rolling maul, South Africa looked a different beast when Marx took to the field.
And that was particularly evident when Marx, alongside props Wilco Louw and Ox Nché, made their way onto the field barely 35 minutes into the game. From that point onwards, the Springboks had a far greater presence at the breakdown, while Marx’s influence was felt across the park.
His performance was outstanding, and it once again highlighted just how much the Boks rely on him to set the physical tone (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-15-why-the-springboks-need-more-than-their-traditional-weapons-to-stay-on-top/), alongside the likes of loose forward Pieter-Steph du Toit. His work at the breakdown, defensive steel, ball-carrying ability and leadership are all crucial components of the Springbok game.
That is why it is difficult to understand why Erasmus would want to leave him out of the starting line-up for a massive Test when he is fit and firing.
It is understandable that the Springbok coach wanted to see what Wessels and props Gerhard Steenekamp and Thomas du Toit could offer from the start. There is a need to build depth, give players opportunities and ensure that the squad is ready for different challenges. But doing so against France, with Marx and the first-choice props fit and available, was arguably not the right occasion to experiment with the starting front row.
The Springboks pride themselves on their depth, particularly in the front row, and have often been able to replace world-class players without suffering a significant drop in standards. But at hooker, the gap between Marx and the rest is currently too significant to ignore.
Bongi Mbonambi is probably the closest the Boks have to a hooker who can start a big Test and allow Marx to make an impact from the bench. However, Mbonambi is still working his way back to his best form after spending a lengthy period out of action. Wessels has plenty of potential, but he is still developing at Test level, while the other options have yet to demonstrate that they can consistently match Marx’s influence.
Against the All Blacks, France, England and Ireland, the Springboks cannot afford to give their opponents an early advantage in the game. The French capitalised on Friday and relied on the 21-7 half-time lead they had built to ensure that the Boks’ late fightback fell just short.
Marx coming off the bench as part of the Bomb Squad can be devastating against tiring opponents. But that argument only holds when there is another hooker capable of maintaining the same level of performance for the opening 40 to 50 minutes.
Right now, there isn’t.
Erasmus needs to keep building his depth for the 2027 Rugby World Cup, for sure, but when the biggest Tests come around, Marx should be one of the first names on the team sheet. You do not leave one of your most influential forwards on the bench when you need to set the tone from the opening whistle. That came back to bite the Boks in Paris.