The Springboks’ forwards kept them in the game against Ireland (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-21-springbok-player-ratings-who-stood-out-in-20-17-defeat-to-ireland/) on Saturday evening, and for a second weekend in a row the world champions had an overreliance on their scrum.
However, Ireland were way better at the set piece than in their last meeting and provided strong opposition in the 20-17 victory (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-22-springboks-refuse-to-point-fingers-after-back-to-back-nations-championship-defeats/), with the Boks not able to come up with alternatives to close out the match. Their discipline also lacked at times, while inaccuracies eventually cost (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-21-siya-kolisi-admits-struggling-springboks-have-plenty-to-fix-after-second-successive-defeat/) them.
Rassie Erasmus and his coaching staff have some important questions to answer, particularly around their attacking structure, backline combinations and over-reliance on certain areas of their game.
Here are five takeaways from the clash at the Aviva Stadium in Dublin.
Attacking shape and chance creation
The Springboks continue to struggle to get their backline firing, with their attacking play lacking fluency, creativity and cohesion. Despite having dangerous players capable of making things happen, South Africa just did not create enough opportunities for their outside backs to exploit and turn into points against the Irish.
The lack of attacking rhythm has become a concern over the last two weekends, particularly against well-organised defences, and needs to be addressed before Finals Weekend.
Aerial-kick execution
The Springboks have built much of their game around aerial pressure, but their reliance on the high ball is not producing the rewards they would expect. Against Ireland, the strategy failed to consistently create opportunities, with the opposition dealing comfortably with much of what was thrown at them.
While it remains an important weapon, the Boks need greater variation and better execution when contesting possession.
Scrum cannot be the only weapon
South Africa’s scrum remains one of their biggest strengths, but it cannot be the only area where they expect to dominate opponents. While winning penalties and putting pressure on opposition front rows are valuable, the Boks need to develop other avenues of attack.
Their inability to consistently threaten Ireland elsewhere highlighted the importance of having a more rounded game, particularly against the world’s leading teams.
Selection and combinations
With the Springboks struggling to find consistency in their attacking play, questions need to be asked about whether their current combinations are delivering the desired results. There is no shortage of individual quality in the squad, but getting the right players together and building an understanding is equally important.
Rassie Erasmus and his coaching staff may need to consider whether fresh combinations can bring greater balance and creativity.
One final throw of the dice to become champions
Despite back-to-back defeats, the Springboks still have an opportunity to finish their Nations Championship campaign as champions. Finals Weekend offers them one last chance to put things right, but they will need to address the shortcomings exposed against Italy, France and Ireland.
The quality is certainly there, but South Africa must rediscover their intensity, accuracy and attacking ambition if they are to lift the trophy.