A jeweller has lost an appeal against a court order compelling him to pay a woman R89,640 (https://iol.co.za/news/crime-and-courts/2026-11-16-appeal-lost-dealer-fined-200000-ordered-to-refund-r276000-after-car-engine-failed-two-days-into-ownership/) after a diamond she handed him for certification was returned as a much less valuable brown stone.
The South Gauteng High Court in Johannesburg dismissed David Graziani’s appeal against a magistrate’s judgment in favour of Angie Spindler, finding that the evidence supported the conclusion that he had substituted her diamond while it was in his possession.
Acting Judges JW Roos and N Mzuzu dismissed the appeal, ordering Graziani to pay Spindler’s legal costs, including those incurred in his unsuccessful application for condonation.
Diamond returned as brown stone
According to the judgment, Spindler owned a solitaire diamond that was a family heirloom.
In 2006, Graziani, a jeweller and diamond mounter, removed the stone from its gold setting and mounted it in a platinum ring.
His certificate described the diamond as weighing 1.04 carats, with colour H and clarity VVS1.
In 2015, he issued another certificate describing it as a 0.987-carat diamond, colour F and clarity VS1. He valued the ring at R135,939.79.
In February 2019, Spindler decided to sell the diamond and handed the ring to Graziani on February 19.
He was instructed to remove the stone, send it to the European Gemological Laboratory (EGL) for certification and buy the platinum setting.
The stone remained in his possession until March 4, 2019, when it was delivered to the laboratory.
The EGL report described the diamond as weighing 0.926 carats, colour L, brown and clarity SI1.
Spindler immediately disputed that it was her diamond.
Graziani subsequently arranged a second certification at his own expense. The Gemological Institute of America reported that the stone weighed 0.92 carats, had colour K and faint brown colouring, with clarity SI1.
Spindler retained the brown diamond.
Jeweller admitted lying to client
The court heard that Graziani had told Spindler, between February 19 and March 4, 2019, that the diamond was already at the laboratory when it was still in his safe.
On February 28, he also told her that the stone’s colour had changed and that it was of a much lower grade, despite the laboratory not having examined it.
During cross-examination, Graziani admitted that he had lied to Spindler about the colour changing to buy himself time.
He also conceded that he had lied about how he calculated the 2015 valuation and that most of his WhatsApp communications with Spindler were untruthful.
He kept no job card, paper trail or video footage relating to the diamond.
Court finds diamond substitution most probable
Spindler initially sued for the return of her diamond, alternatively claiming its value if Graziani had disposed of it knowing that it belonged to her.
The magistrate dismissed the claim for the return of the diamond but upheld her alternative damages claim.
Graziani was ordered to pay R89,640, with interest at 7.75% from June 9, 2020, and to return the brown stone to him against payment.
The High Court found that the magistrate had correctly accepted Spindler’s version and rejected Graziani’s.
The judges said the most probable inference from the evidence was that Graziani had substituted the diamond.
They pointed to his exclusive possession of the stone during the relevant period, his repeated lies about its whereabouts and his admission that he had falsely told Spindler its colour had changed before it was examined.
The court said his February 28 statement was particularly significant.
“There was no innocent way for the appellant to know on that date that a lower grade stone would come back,” the judges said.
They added that his explanation that he had lied to buy time did not answer the issue but confirmed it.
The possibility that his driver or the laboratory could have swapped the diamond was dismissed as a theoretical possibility that did not displace the probabilities.
R89,640 damages upheld
The court also rejected Graziani’s challenge to the valuation of the diamond.
Spindler’s expert, Alan Lowe, calculated the diamond’s value using the international Rapaport benchmark price, less a 40% trading discount.
The calculation based on the 2015 certificate came to R89,640, while the returned brown stone was valued at R17,001.60.
The judges said the valuation was supported by evidence and had not been contradicted by Graziani, who called no expert witness.
They also upheld the magistrate’s order requiring Spindler to return the brown stone against payment, saying it prevented her from recovering more than her actual loss.
The High Court concluded that the elements of the alternative damages claim had been established and that there was no basis to interfere with the magistrate’s findings.
The appeal was dismissed, with Graziani ordered to pay Spindler’s legal costs.
sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za
IOL News
Get your news on the go. Download the latest IOL App for Android (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.iol.news.prod&hl=en_ZA&pli=1) and IOS (https://apps.apple.com/za/app/iol-news/id479535200) now.