News

‘Silly Ideas’ for Holding South Africa’s Politicians Accountable

todayNovember 17, 2026 13

Background
share close

The 2026 Local Government Elections are over. The votes have been counted, the winners are celebrating, the losers are consulting their strategists, and somewhere in South Africa, coalition negotiations are probably taking place over coffee, lunch and promises of positions. The voters have spoken. Now comes the difficult part: governing.

But what if, just for a moment, we entertained a few ridiculous ideas? Not the usual promises of clean governance, accelerated service delivery, economic transformation and fighting corruption. We have heard those promises before. What if we introduced rules so absurd that they might actually force our public representatives to do what they were elected to do?

Welcome to the Republic of Silly Ideas.

Silly Idea No. 1: Every elected official must drive their own car and live in their own home

Why should taxpayers automatically fund the trappings of power when an official’s primary responsibility is to serve them?

Let ministers, mayors and councillors use their own vehicles where reasonably practicable, subject to transparent and properly justified arrangements for official travel. Where government transport is genuinely necessary, the public should know why it is needed, how much it costs and how it is used.

We are not suggesting that officials should be denied legitimate work-related expenses. We are asking why public office so often appears to come with a lifestyle upgrade.

Silly Idea No. 2: No VIP protection. Except, of course, where a genuine security assessment demands it

Why should every position of political importance automatically be accompanied by a convoy, flashing lights and an entourage?

Security must be based on credible threats, not ego or rank. The President and other officials facing demonstrable threats must receive appropriate protection. But the public should not be expected to fund unnecessary displays of importance.

Perhaps our leaders should occasionally experience the traffic, potholes and public transport frustrations that ordinary citizens endure.

It might even improve their understanding of service delivery.

Silly Idea No. 3: A portion of every senior official’s remuneration should be linked to performance

Imagine a world in which senior officials receive their full guaranteed salary only after meeting clearly defined performance standards.

A portion of their remuneration could be placed in a performance-linked arrangement and released against independently verified results. The criteria would have to be published in advance, be within the official’s reasonable control and account for emergencies, inherited failures and other external factors.

The assessment should be based on actual outcomes, not the number of meetings attended, speeches delivered or reports produced.

Did the municipality reduce water losses? Were roads repaired to the required standard? Were invoices paid on time? Did the department meet its targets for processing applications? No delivery, no performance bonus.

The guaranteed salary would remain subject to employment law and the applicable remuneration framework. This is about earning additional performance-linked pay, not withholding wages unlawfully.

Silly Idea No. 4: Every public representative must sign a Citizen Service Contract

Within 100 days of taking office, every councillor, mayor and relevant executive authority must publish a contract stating:

What they intend to deliver.How much it will cost.Who is responsible.When it will be completed.How the public will verify success.What corrective action follows if targets are missed.

No more vague promises about creating jobs, improving infrastructure or fighting corruption. Give us the numbers. Give us the deadlines. Give us the evidence.

Silly Idea No. 5: Corruption should be treated as economic sabotage

Any official convicted of serious corruption, money laundering or the deliberate abuse of public procurement for personal gain should face penalties that reflect the damage inflicted on society. We should explore legislation providing stronger penalties for aggravated public-sector corruption, including proportionate financial penalties, asset recovery, appropriate imprisonment and disqualification from public office where legally justified. Three times the normal penalty for ordinary criminals? That is the provocative proposition. The serious reform is to ensure that punishment is lawful, proportionate and consistently enforced, while strengthening the recovery of stolen public money. Allegations must still be investigated fairly, and guilt established through due process.

We must also confront nepotism and patronage. Family connections should never substitute for qualifications, competence or a fair procurement process.

Silly Idea No. 6: If you cannot do the job, you cannot keep the job

A public official who repeatedly fails to meet agreed performance standards should face a formal performance improvement process, followed by appropriate disciplinary action where warranted. Where incapacity, misconduct or persistent failure is established through a fair process, dismissal should be a real possibility, not an unthinkable political inconvenience. However, poor performance must be distinguished from deliberate misconduct. A municipal manager cannot manufacture clean water out of an empty reservoir, nor can a councillor single-handedly repair a network of failing infrastructure without resources.The test must be whether the official did everything reasonably required to deliver, manage resources responsibly and address problems transparently.

Employment equity must not be suspended as a punishment for non-performance. Equal opportunity, transformation and accountability are compatible objectives. The standard must be competence, fairness and results.

Silly Idea No. 7: Publish the diary!

Every minister, mayor, councillor and senior public official should maintain an online public diary showing official meetings, site visits, community engagements and significant decisions. The public should know who met whom, what the meeting was about, what decisions followed and whether promised actions were completed.

Legitimate exceptions must apply to confidential personal information, legally privileged discussions and genuine security-sensitive matters.

We do not need to know where a minister sleeps. We do need to know whether the minister is working.

Silly Idea No. 8: A citizens’ jury for matters of public importance

For major procurement decisions, large infrastructure projects and significant policy choices, randomly selected, appropriately trained citizens could participate in independent oversight panels. These panels would scrutinise evidence, question officials and publish findings. They would complement, rather than replace, professional procurement processes, elected councils, auditors and the courts. For genuine national-security matters, a suitably cleared, independent oversight body could examine decisions under strict confidentiality rules and report publicly on whether the law and proper procedures were followed.The principle is simple: confidentiality should protect the country, not conceal incompetence or corruption.

Silly Idea No. 9: One ward meeting every month. No excuses without an explanation

Every ward councillor should hold at least one properly advertised public meeting each month, with an accessible alternative for residents who cannot attend in person.

Minutes, attendance figures, complaints, commitments and outstanding issues should be published. But here is the important part: the meeting is not the achievement. Resolving the problems raised is the achievement. A councillor who holds 12 meetings a year but never follows up on a burst pipe, a dangerous road or a prolonged electricity fault has simply become an excellent meeting organiser.

Silly Idea No. 10: Put every tender under public scrutiny

Every public contract should have a digital trail, from the original procurement notice to the final payment. The public should be able to see the tender requirements, evaluation criteria, winning bidder, contract value, relevant beneficial ownership information, amendments, project milestones and evidence of completion.

Independent reviewers should be able to flag suspicious patterns, conflicts of interest and unexplained cost increases. South Africa should build on existing procurement rules and strengthen open contracting, with carefully defined protections for personal information, legitimate commercial confidentiality and security-sensitive information. Much like Takealot, programmes should be tracked online until delivery! A contract should not disappear into a filing cabinet once the winning company has been announced.

These ideas are not all fantasies. Some have practical counterparts in other countries.

Brazil: Let citizens influence the budget.

Participatory budgeting, associated with Porto Alegre, Brazil, gives residents a structured role in identifying priorities and scrutinising municipal spending. South African municipalities could set aside a defined portion of discretionary capital spending for projects selected through transparent community processes, subject to feasibility and affordability. The World Bank has documented the development of this approach.

South Korea: Put procurement online from beginning to end.

South Korea’s KONEPS electronic procurement system connects major stages of procurement, including bidding, contracting and payment. Its approach offers a model for reducing unnecessary face-to-face dealings and improving transparency. South Africa could strengthen its own systems by linking tender announcements, contract awards, delivery records and payments.

Estonia: Make government work for the citizen.

Estonia’s digital-government model applies the principle that citizens should not repeatedly provide information that government already lawfully holds. South Africa could move towards integrated applications, shared records and one-stop services, while protecting privacy and maintaining accessible non-digital options.

The United Kingdom: Publish meaningful performance data.

UK government service guidance calls for public bodies to define success, measure outcomes and publish performance data. South African departments and municipalities could adopt similarly clear service standards, allowing residents to compare performance and identify where interventions are needed.

These examples are not magic solutions. Technology cannot compensate for dishonest leadership, and publishing information is not the same as acting on it. But they demonstrate that practical mechanisms exist to make public spending more visible, services easier to access and officials more answerable for results.

The ballot box is not a blank cheque

South Africans have just exercised their democratic right to choose their local representatives. For many communities, the next five years will be determined not only by who won the most votes, but also by whether coalition partners can govern responsibly and whether municipal administrations can deliver basic services.

Our challenge is not to replace democracy with a system of punishment. It is to make democracy work between elections.

We need competent officials, honest procurement, transparent budgets, functioning infrastructure, responsive councillors and consequences for proven misconduct. We need political parties to treat public office as a responsibility rather than an entitlement.

And we need citizens to do more than vote, complain and wait for the next campaign.

Ask your councillor for the ward plan. Attend the public meeting. Read the municipal budget. Follow the tender. Demand the completion date. Ask what happened to the last promise. If the answers are inadequate, document them and demand accountability through the appropriate channels.

These are “silly” ideas only because we have become accustomed to the possibility that public power can be exercised without sufficient public consequence. Perhaps the time has come to turn that absurdity on its head.

Public office is not a private reward. It is a public trust. And if that sounds like a radical proposition, then perhaps South Africa needs a little more radical common sense.

By a concerned citizen

Written by: IOL News

Rate it

Previous post

Sports

‘Manipulation of the result’: Fuming Rassie blasts officiating and disciplinary double standards

Rassie Erasmus (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-16-springboks-determined-to-restore-standards-against-ireland-after-paris-disappointment/) has questioned whether match officials who knowingly ignore foul play (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-17-hell-play-on-saturday-rassie-blasts-terrible-sam-prendergast-hip-drop-tackle/) could be accused of influencing a Test match’s outcome. The fuming Springbok coach also launched a stinging attack on what he sees as inconsistencies in rugby’s disciplinary process. Speaking ahead of Saturday’s Nations Championship showdown against Ireland in Dublin, (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-16-rassie-reshuffles-springboks-pack-as-eben-etzebeth-returns-for-ireland-showdown/) Erasmus revisited the Boks’ 21-19 defeat to France in Paris, claiming Les Bleus escaped punishment for […]

todayNovember 17, 2026 12


Magic 828

Magic 828 AM is a South African commercial radio station playing the best of hits from the 80s, 90s and 2000’s

Download Our App

Don’t miss a track or memorable tune. Download the Magic828 App now on your mobile phone by clicking here!

0%