Listeners:
Top listeners:
play_arrow
Techno Radio Top Music Radio
play_arrow
London Calling Podcast Yana Bolder
The casting of Cynthia Erivo as South African music icon Miriam Makeba in the upcoming musical drama, “The Road Home”, has sparked widespread debate across South Africa.
The R300 million production will explore the lives of Makeba and fellow jazz legend Hugh Masekela, focusing on their experiences during apartheid and their connection to Paul Simon’s historic “Graceland” tour.
The film is set to be shot in Cape Town and will also star Thabo Rametsi and Guy Pearce.
While Erivo is an award-winning performer known for her portrayal of Harriet Tubman, her casting as Makeba has divided public opinion.
Many South Africans have taken to social media to express disappointment, arguing that the role should have gone to a local actress or singer who can authentically capture Makeba’s linguistic and cultural identity.
Below are a few of the online reactions:
@comfy86 said: “Cynthia playing Miriam? That’s interesting. That woman was a pure Xhosa woman. Those clicks will be hectic.”
@MaKhumz33 said: “This will be as ridiculous and hilarious as that time Jennifer Hudson and Idris Elba tried to speak Xhosa and do a South African accent… Americans MUST stop this nonsense. We have perfectly capable actors in Africa who can embody Mama Makeba with the right language and accent.”
Critics have particularly highlighted concerns around language, noting that Makeba was a proud isiXhosa speaker.
Others feel the casting reflects a broader trend of international productions overlooking local talent.
However, not all reactions have been negative. Some social media users have expressed confidence in Erivo’s ability to deliver a compelling performance:
@its_judina said: “Cynthia played Harriet so perfectly for Americans, and she’s British. I’m sorry, guys, I don’t know why I have so much faith in her killing this role. We are going to be praising her.”
Media personality Somizi Mhlongo also joined the conversation, acknowledging the frustration felt by many South Africans while offering a broader industry perspective.
He said: “Most South Africans are not happy, including myself. I’m not happy about these Hollywood, overseas producers taking our stories and telling our stories. I understand the frustration – it is valid, it is warranted.
“But we must also consider that these things have been happening forever. The person funding the project calls the shots – they decide who plays the lead, where it’s filmed and how the story is told.
“From a business perspective, the person investing wants a return on their investment. We have the best actors in this country, globally competitive, but do they always make business sense? I love Cynthia, I think she’s amazing.
“So if you’re looking at it from a business perspective, don’t stress yourself.”
The controversy highlights an ongoing conversation about representation in global cinema – particularly who gets to tell African stories and portray African icons.
As anticipation builds for “The Road Home”, the discussion around authenticity, opportunity, and commercial viability continues to resonate both locally and internationally.
Whether Erivo’s performance will win over sceptics remains to be seen, but the casting has undeniably reignited important conversations about ownership and representation in storytelling.
Music streaming giant Spotify said Tuesday that first-quarter revenue rose as its number of monthly active users reached 761 million at the end of the quarter, with the number of paying subscribers hitting 293 million.The result was just above the company's guidance of 759 million monthly active users (MAU), while the number of paying subscribers was in line with its guidance."We surpassed 760 million MAU, delivered on the subscriber growth […]
Magic 828 AM is a South African commercial radio station playing the best of hits from the 80s, 90s and 2000’s
Don’t miss a track or memorable tune. Download the Magic828 App now on your mobile phone by clicking here!
