Springboks (https://iol.co.za/tags/springboks/) fans would have been unsure whether to laugh or cry at the final whistle in Dublin on Saturday night after losing 20-17 to Ireland (https://iol.co.za/tags/ireland-rugby/), yet advancing to the final of the inaugural Nations Championship.
The Springboks have finished top of the Southern Hemisphere (https://iol.co.za/sport/rugby/springboks/2026-11-21-live-springboks-and-ireland-set-for-aviva-stadium-showdown-in-nations-championship/) log to move past New Zealand, but if they hope to win the trophy next week at Twickenham, they need to find the mojo that has gone missing in the last fortnight in Europe.
The Boks have lost back to back matches for the first time since 2022.
England’s 37-12 humbling of New Zealand earlier in the day had given the Boks extra motivation: a win over Ireland would put them at the top of the Southern Hemisphere table and into next week’s final in London for the inaugural Nations Championship trophy.
In fact, all they needed was one point to draw level with New Zealand because the Boks’ points difference was vastly superior. They secured that point courtesy of losing by less than seven points.
Of course, the Bok players’ main focus was expunging the pain of the defeat to France the week before, and cocking a snook at the World Rugby bosses who banned their coach.
But Ireland were on a smother and suffocate mission, and the Boks had no answer. The South Africans didn’t win much possession, and when they did, they looked lost on what to do with it.
A big issue coming out of this game, and after the previous week’s loss to France, is that flyhalf Sacha Feinberg Mngomezulu is increasingly resembling what cricket calls a flat track bully. He is a wonder boy behind a winning pack, but mediocre when his forwards are matched.
He was awful in Paris and just as poor in Dublin.
Jan Hendrik Wessels, on trial as backup hooker to Malcolm Marx, failed with his inability to throw the ball into the lineout.
The Springboks started with strong intent, and scrum penalties were immediate, one of which Feinberg Mngomezulu goaled.
Ireland responded with frenetic play from the kick off, and a siege in the Boks’ 22 eventually created space for winger Rob Baloucoune to coast over untouched.
Sam Prendergast missed the conversion, leaving Ireland up 5-3 after 10 minutes.
The wind was in the Irish sails, and they flew back into the Boks’ 22, where only a dogged tackle by Cameron Hanekom forced Baloucoune into losing the ball as he reached over the line.
From the resulting scrum, the Boks did what they do best and won a penalty to relieve the pressure, but Ireland lock Joe McCarthy won a penalty at the breakdown to restore it. This time Baloucoune went over in the corner for his second.
The pressure on the Boks escalated in the 25th minute when Damian Willemse limped off and was replaced by Canan Moodie.
The roof almost rose at Aviva Stadium when Ireland won a scrum penalty thanks to a curious interpretation by referee Christophe Ridley.
In the 30th minute, the Boks’ best attack was a breakout from deep in the SA half by Kurt Lee Arendse and support runner Canan Moodie. It culminated in a scrum five metres from the tryline, and the Bok pack propelled the Irish scrum almost into the stands, with Morne van den Berg darting over for his ninth try in his 14th Test.
But the Boks blew it with a schoolboy error. From the restart, they criminally had Moodie in front of the kicker. Ireland kicked to the corner, and hooker Ronan Kelleher bustled over as the half time hooter sounded. Prendergast’s conversion meant a 17-10 half time lead.
I don’t know what coach Erasmus said on his online show, but I would be surprised if there weren’t choice expletives.
Moodie redeemed himself with a strong surge to the corner flag, but part of his body was in touch as he grounded the ball.
The Bomb Squad was deployed in the 47th minute, and South Africa needed them to detonate.
Poor officiating decisions on Irish tackles around the neck added salt to the wounds when a penalty against the Boks saw Prendergast kick it. That put the Boks out of contention for the final at 20-10.
They were back in it when Malcolm Marx muscled over after a rare passage of assured Springbok phase play.
The Boks seemed to be gaining the ascendancy, only for Wessels to horribly mess up two lineout throws.
Then Marco van Staden was yellow carded for doing a Jasper Wiese in charging into a ruck head first.
Ireland held on for a victory that raises the question about whether this Springbok side is in decline.
Scorers
Ireland — Tries: Robert Baloucoune (2), Ronan Kelleher. Conversion: Sam Prendergast. Penalty: Prendergast
South Africa — Tries: Morne van den Berg, Malcolm Marx. Conversions: Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu (2). Penalty: Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu.